Based upon reading the
graphic novel "We Are on Our Own" Miriam Katin portrays the events
that occurred in WWII. Miriam emphasizes on her perception of war and
tragedy which can be greatly understood from a younger age groups point of
view. The tragedies of the world wars are contextualized through her
illustrations and writing within this novel.
We are On Our Own visualizes Miriam’s life after war and the changes she
goes through in her daily life. The book starts of with
Esther Levy, who is Miriam’s mother who takes care of
two-year-old Miriam alone in Nazi-occupied Budapest while her husband fights in
the Hungarian army In 1944 there were Over 184,000 Jewish people in Budapest..
This graphic novel can be seen as part of history and the war. This novel shows
what Miriams family has gone through while her father was at war and her mother
was striving to keep both herself and Miriam away from the Nazi Hunters. Esther stays out of the way of being found by living
on a farm. When Trouble comes around
when the local Nazi Commandant spies her. Suspecting she is a Jew, instead of
turning her in, he forces her to become his mistress. Soon this horror gives
way to another as the Nazis retreat from the advancing Russian troops. The
Russian's vodka-fueled barbarism sends Esther fleeing into a snowstorm, pulling
Miriam behind her. This shows that many victims had to live in hiding for years
before the war was over. Because the perspective is that of a very young child,
the readers are spared some of the horrifying details that can often be found
in Holocaust stories.

Based upon Miriam growing up in budapest i thought that this video would give us more insight and a visual view of what was going on in Budapest at the time of the war in 1944.
http://www.criticalpast.com/video/65675032365_peace-meeting_marchers_banners_posters_torch
Hi Jessica,
ReplyDeleteI find that although the book has a historical aspect to it it is not reliable. The fact that the book was written by a child based on what she recalls or thinks that she recalls make the story biased and not reliable. The book does give an insight into what many people may have been subjected to endure during WW2 but it fails to provide reliable, factual information.
https://scholar.lib.vt.edu/ejournals/ALAN/v42n3/pdf/robbins.pdf
ReplyDeleteThis link discussed the potential of utilizing graphic memoirs to engage students in the learning of history